Ivory stucco home entrance with an oak door, bronze-framed window, worn limestone steps and a raised bed of bird-of-paradise and aeonium.

Belmont Shore 2nd Street: New Restaurants and Returning Names

The storefront at 5269 E. 2nd St. used to be a European Wax Center. Its next tenant is a business that started in 1945 as Dot & Bob Candies on Balboa Island and changed its name to Sugar 'N Spice in 1959. The owners have said they hope to be open in time for the Belmont Shore Christmas Parade, according to Longbeachize.

That one lease follows a pattern on 2nd Street this fall. Most of the spaces that have changed hands since June are going to businesses with a long history somewhere else. One is a Naples name that closed more than a decade ago and is planning a return. The parades in early December are the first big deadline for all of them.

Who's Moving Into Which Storefront

Here is every change on and around 2nd Street that local press has reported since early summer, matched to the space it is taking.

Business Address or space What was there before Latest reported status
South of Nick's 5354 E. 2nd St. Not reported Opening set for June 22, per a May report
CoffeeDrunk 4708 E. 2nd St. Aroma di Roma Open, reported July 6
Sugar 'N Spice 5269 E. 2nd St. European Wax Center Announced, no opening date
Mandala Spice & Grill 5262 E. Second St. Natraj Announced, no opening date
Bacio di Latte Belmont Shore Holey Grail Announced, no opening date
Kelly's Steakhouse Former Chianina and 4 Shore building Chianina, then 4 Shore Building purchased, details still with the city

The two summer arrivals came first. Longbeachize reported in May that South of Nick's would open June 22 at 5354 E. 2nd St., its first Long Beach location. By July 6, the outlet reported that CoffeeDrunk's Belmont Shore location was open in the old Aroma di Roma space at 4708 E. 2nd St.

The four fall announcements are where the history shows up.

The Belmont Bar Shows How the Imports Are Fitting In

Sugar 'N Spice built its name on Marine Avenue, Balboa Island's short commercial strip. It is known for hand-dipped frozen bananas and the Balboa Bar, an ice cream bar dipped in chocolate and topped to order. The menu also includes frozen cheesecake and soft serve.

In Belmont Shore, the shop is renaming its signature item. The Balboa Bar will be sold here as the Belmont Bar. The Belmont Shore Business Association's head treated that as the main news. Heather Kern told Longbeachize:

"They've been a Balboa Island tradition for over 80 years, and now they're bringing that history to 2nd Street. We love that Balboa Bars are becoming Belmont Bars, starting a whole new tradition right here in Belmont Shore."

The rename shows how 2nd Street is taking these businesses in. A Newport Beach shop is bringing 80 years of history and giving its best-known product a local name. As of the October 9 report, no opening date had been set, so the parade target is a hope, not a promise.

Bacio di Latte fits the same pattern from much farther away. The gelato chain was founded in 2011 by Milanese brothers Edoardo and Luigi Tonolli on Rua Oscar Freire in São Paulo, Brazil, after they traveled through Italy studying traditional recipes. It is taking the former Holey Grail space and plans more than 20 flavors, including pistacchio, giandujotto, cioccolato Belga and Nutellina, according to the October 16 Long Beach Food Scene Intel roundup.

That puts two established dessert brands on the same few blocks, one from Orange County's beach history and one with Italian recipes and Brazilian roots. Neither has announced an opening date.

Kelly's Is the Oldest Name Coming Back

Kelly's carries the deepest local history of anything on the list. It opened in Naples in 1958 and served steaks, seafood and martinis. When it closed in 2013, it was the oldest steakhouse in the city, and at its peak it was considered one of Long Beach's best restaurants.

The same October 16 roundup reported that George Mlouk, the owner of Nico's, has bought the building that housed Chianina and then 4 Shore. Longbeachize writer Brian Addison confirmed that rumors of a Kelly's-style restaurant there are true and that Kelly's Steakhouse is returning. Mlouk is still working out details with the city, and no timeline has been published.

Kelly's is different from the other fall announcements because its history comes from this neighborhood, not from somewhere else. The building has also had two restaurant identities since Kelly's closed. That makes the return a test of whether the name can draw people back after 13 years. For anyone who ate at the original in Naples, it is the opening on this list most worth watching. It is also the one with the least certain timing, because the city still has to sign off on the details.

Mandala Spice & Grill Takes Over a Familiar Address

Not every new tenant arrives with a decades-long backstory. Mandala Spice & Grill, a Nepali-Indian fusion restaurant, is moving into the former Natraj storefront at 5262 E. Second St. The October 16 roundup showed its chicken sekuwa and said a fuller look at the menu was coming in the following weeks. No opening date or operator name has been published yet.

The address will be familiar to anyone who knew it as Natraj. Mandala at 5262 and Sugar 'N Spice at 5269 have neighboring street numbers on 2nd Street, which makes them the two most recent announcements to check on during a single walk.

The Calendar These Openings Are Working Toward

The Belmont Shore Business Association says the district covers 28 blocks of businesses. Between now and mid-December, the street's own calendar is the most likely place to see which of the announced openings are actually ready. Here are the dates, starting this weekend:

  1. Trick-or-treat on 2nd Street, Saturday, October 31, 4 to 6 p.m. This is the first big foot-traffic day of the season, and it's two days after this post publishes. Details are on the Belmont Shore event page.
  2. Naples Island Improvement Association general membership meeting, Tuesday, November 17, 6 to 8 p.m., at Long Beach Yacht Club. The association says the meeting is open to all members and includes community updates.
  3. Small Business Saturday "Shop the Shore," Saturday, November 28, 8 a.m. to 9:59 p.m. The business association is advertising free parking all day, which is uncommon on 2nd Street.
  4. 42nd Annual Belmont Shore Christmas Parade, Saturday, December 5, 6 to 9 p.m. The parade is held on the first Saturday of December and features 100 entries, including over a dozen local marching bands and floats from Long Beach businesses and associations. Entries finish by heading back west to Livingston Avenue along the north side of East Second Street.
  5. Naples Island Holiday Boat Parade, Saturday, December 12, 7 to 8 p.m. The boats light up Alamitos Bay and the Naples Canals, per the Naples Island Improvement Association.

The December 5 parade is the date Sugar 'N Spice has named as its goal. The business association calls it one of the biggest parades of the year in Long Beach, with families lining up along 2nd Street for a seat. A storefront that's still papered over on parade night misses that crowd, and a shop that's open gets the parade route right outside its door.

Planning Around the Street Through the Holidays

For anyone who already walks 2nd Street every week, here's what the next two months look like. CoffeeDrunk at 4708 E. 2nd St. was open by July, and South of Nick's was set to open at 5354 E. 2nd St. in June. Trick-or-treat on October 31 is a good chance to walk by 5262 and 5269 and see how close they are to opening. Small Business Saturday on November 28 is the easiest day to park, because the business association is covering it. Parade night on December 5 will show whether the Belmont Bar is actually on sale. Kelly's will keep its own schedule, set by the city's review, and the original Naples name won't be rushed to make a holiday deadline.

At Joseph Cordi, we follow Belmont Shore and Naples down to the building level. If you own near 2nd Street and want to know how this turnover affects your home's position, let's connect.

Work With Joseph

As an agent who's an expert in this local area, I bring a wealth of knowledge and expertise about buying and selling real estate here. It's not the same everywhere, so you need someone you can trust for up-to-date information. I am eager to serve you.

Follow Me on Instagram